Best Reality Show of 2011: X Factor vs. Idol


Hey M Girls!

It's almost time to kiss 2011 goodbye forever, but before we do, let's recap: Every day for the next month, M will ask YOU to vote on the Best of the Year -- from movies, music, fashion trends and more.

Today's topic is "Best Reality Show" and our two nominees are XFactor and American Idol!

Vote for either show (or choose "Other") below, then make your arguments in the comments section!

This poll will close at midnight tonight, and we'll have the next category up right after!

More "Best of 2011": Best Book of 2011 Best Hip-Hop Artist of 2011 Best Newcomer of 2011 Best Movie of 2011

Keep up with your fave celebs in the pages of M Magazine by subscribing now!